Kelly Clarkson – Dark Side

“Not as good as Stronger”.

Tom: I can sum this up in five words: “not as good as Stronger”.

Tim: Agreed.

Tom: Which is a shame, because I want to like this song – and not just because I like Kelly Clarkson. It’s got a cracking chorus when it kicks in, but it’s spoiled by a few things. The calmer “will you love me / even with my dark side” bit just seems out of place, and the video just seems melodramatic and fake.

Tim: It me, it seems…a bit dull. Yes, it gets going towards the end, but since you opened this review comparing it to Stronger I now want something as big as that was. It’s YOUR FAULT I’m disappointed, Tom Scott. YOUR FAULT.

Tom: Pink does this kind of song and video very well: the “people aren’t ideal, but try to cope with them” track that’s got an emotional punch that’ll make teenage girls cry. And this track is trying so hard – too hard – to be that. But on the back of Stronger, it just seems like a poor imitation.

Tim: You’re MAKING IT WORSE.

Little Boots – Headphones

A proper electropop dance track.

Tom: The lovely thing about certain artists is that you can tell it’s them just from how they sound.

Tim: Very true.

Tom: Little Boots has just such a sound, and my word, it’s a good one.

Tom: Okay, so the “la la la” chorus is a bit unimaginative, and the rest of the lyrics are a bit meaningless and ridiculous, but none of that really matters, because it’s a proper electropop dance track.

Tim: But if it’s a track about music in general, “la la la” is fairly appropriate if you’re going to have a recurrent theme.

Tom: A bit more poppy than her previous album, perhaps – but that’s by no means a bad thing.

Tim: I’d go so far as to say: it’s a good thing. Although I would say that at four minutes and with such a notable, recurring theme going on, it sounds a bit drawn out at the end. That’s my only criticism, though.

Agnes – One Last Time

Whoa. That is emotional.

Tim: Remember Agnes, off of four years ago?

Tom: Nope.

Tim: Yes you do, you know, her.

Tom: Oh, her.

Tom: Whoa. That is emotional.

Tim: Bit different, isn’t it? Previously was CLUB BANGER, but now we have beat-heavy ballad, and I like it. Partly because it’s been a while since I heard a song where the emotion of the lyrics is mirrored so perfectly in both the delivery of them and the music behind them.

Tom: Sinéad O’Connor’s version of “Nothing Compares 2 U” comes to mind. Not because this song’s equal to it – it’s a good track, but it’s not that good – but becaues it has that perfect match between vocals and instrumentation.

Tim: Right. Normally something seems a tad off – maybe it’s a bit too fast, or the voice is too excited – but here it just seems to work. She’s not too over-the-top screamy desperate, and the music’s got just the right amount of, well, whatever it is that it needs to be right. (That made sense in my head, I promise.)

Tom: Once I parsed that sentence, I can only agree.

Tim: It’s even there in the video – the quiet longing, not overplayed but just enough to really get you if you’re feeling a bit emotional. Basically, here everything goes together perfectly, and because of that, full marks.

Tom: It’s a proper break-up song. If you’re in the mood for that, well, it will do the job nicely.

DJ Fresh feat. Dizzee Rascal – The Power

That’s two very different songs jammed together.

Tom: DJ Fresh, purveyor of top-quality dance CHOONS. Dizzee Rascal, one of the most energetic live performers I’ve ever seen. Surely this can’t be anything other than spectacularly good?

Tom: Okay, that’s not the best start, but I’m sure it’ll pick up… huh. That’s… well. That’s two very different songs jammed together. One’s an 80s-inspired synth singalong, and the other’s a bassline-fuelled Dizzee rap track. And it keeps switching between the two.

Tim: Yes, it does, doesn’t it?

Tom: And I like it.

Tim: Ah, a difference of opinion.

Tom: Here’s the thing: I can’t explain why I like it. Maybe it’s just because these two are clearly so damned good; even when it seems a bit disjointed, the various parts are still so energetic and danceable that they just work anyway.

Tim: You think? Yes, they’re energetic and danceable, but whenever Mr Rascal’s doing his stuff, I’m thinking, “Hurry up, bring back the other bit,” but when they do bring back the other bit I think that Dizzee needs to come back or it’ll get annoying. And then he does come back, and I want him to go away again. Oh, I DON’T KNOW.

Youngblood – American Girlfriend

This song is ridiculous.

Tim: Youngblood: a newish Swedish boyband, who had a flop debut single last year, announced themselves vaguely successfully to the world at Melodifestivalen, and are following up with this.

Tim: Right. First off, let’s get the inevitable out of the way: this song is ridiculous.

Tom: “Fell in love, face first?” No. You can fall in water face first. Or, if you’re Biff from Back to the Future, you can fall in manure face first. You can’t fall in love face first.

Tim: That’s what you’re going for first? Because musically, it’s standard boyband fare, so not particularly interesting, but lyrics-wise, it’s a whole other ball game. We have a Swedish band singing about how they know London so well, but desperately want a girl from New York. It makes no sense, and to be honest it wouldn’t remotely surprise me if this is a song that got rejected by One Direction’s management.

Tom: That’d explain the London references: switch it to a British band and it all makes sense. In fact: that’s pretty much the only explanation, sure?

Tim: Probably, yes, but it’s it’s not like it’s just the lyrics. There’s also the video, which opens with them encouraging a group of girls who’ve doubtless never heard of them before to sing along to their last song, and then mostly appears to have been shot with Instagram filters for no good reason whatsoever.

Tom: Ever since I’ve moved to London, videos like this annoy me. It’s the kind of thing that, as a Londoner, I’m going to have to grumpily navigate around as I make my way through the city.

Tim: Huh, see I quite like things like that. Like when I’m watching Fringe and I see a part of Vancouver I recognise, I’m a bit “Ooh, I know that.” Though admittedly it’s getting a bit dull now it’s London.

Anyway, stupid and ridiculous as this song is: I love it.

Tom: What?

Tim: I think it’s great. I can’t write that without laughing at myself for thinking it, but as far as I’m concerned it’s fantastic. And you won’t convince me otherwise.

Tom: It’s a fine line between “formulaic but good” and “utter pap”, and this falls squarely on the wrong side of that line.

Tim: Probably, but I DON’T CARE.

Gary Barlow & The Commonwealth Band feat. Military Wives – Sing

“…like some kind of beardy musical messiah”

Tom: Right, brace yourself, Tim. It’s Summer Charity Songs today and tomorrow.

Tim: Oh, really?

Tom: We start with this one, for the Jubilee.

Tim: Well, it would take a special kind of person who negatively reviews that, so I won’t be him. But I will say: oh, bloody hell.

Tom: First of all, let’s get the ridiculous bits out of the way: yes, it has Gary Barlow travelling the world like some kind of beardy musical messiah on a walkabout. Yes, it has a conductor in a bow tie. And yes, it’s almost certainly inspired by the wonderful, world-wide cover of Stand By Me that did the rounds.

Tim: Ridiculous-wise, those things don’t even compare to it. What about the opening?

Tom: Yes, there are more ridiculous things here. It starts with Prince Charles listening to it. And Prince Charles is inherently ridiculous. Full marks to Prince Harry, mind, for amiably handling his occasional tambourine taps with a knowing grin.

Tim: Well, there is that.

Tom: Actually, hang on: there’s more ridiculous things. They rhymed “sing it clearer” and “everyone will hear ya”. Not “you”. “Ya”. Plus, it’s partly written by Andrew Lloyd Webber. Plus, plus, plus, there isn’t even a damned key change, and if ever a song needed one…

Tim: Yes – it really does go on, doesn’t it? Especially the marching band bit at the end, which sounds horribly disjointed from the rest of it.

Tom: The thing is, it’s not a bad piece of music. It’s just a bit ridiculous.

Emma Lewin – Tro, Hopp & Kärlek

That’s more syrupy than a maple sap convention.

Tim: Tom, if you’d be so good as to reach behind you and sound the SCHLAGERTASTIC SIREN, we can begin.

Tom: WOOP WOOP! That’s the sound of… oh. The police, apparently. I think I’ve lost my siren.

Tom: Oh god, that’s more syrupy than a maple sap convention. (Sorry about that: sound the APPALLING ANALOGY SIREN, please.)

Tim: WOOP WOOP! That’s the sound of the APPALLING ANALOGY SIREN – I look after my toys. But it is syrupy, isn’t it, and beautifully so.

It’s all in there from the intro – the annoyingly upbeat singing, the gentle ‘start tapping your feet NOW’ tune behind it. Admittedly the verse isn’t all that, but the chorus is something you’ll either loathe or, if you’re sensible (and if you’re reading this you probably are), not be able to help swaying to, desperately trying to keep your hands by your side rather than waving them in the air like a commuting nutjob.

Tom: I was all ready to loathe it, and then I realised that my foot was automatically tapping along. DAMN YOU LEWIN.

Tim: And then there’s the obligatory you-know-what.

Tom: Voldemort? Oh, key change, got it.

Tim: It’s not as spectacular as it might be.

Tom: Neither was Voldemort. He gets the wind machines and pyrotechnics, but does he have backup dancers? No. He’d never win Eurovision, that’s for sure.

Tim: Well, the closest thing he’d have would be backup dementors, and they’d really kill the mood. But if we could move back to reality for a second, I’d have liked some sort of musical explosion in the background for said key change, even though that would sound totally out place, but we can’t have everything. But you know the best thing? This doesn’t sound out of date. Schlager’s a style of music that by all rights should be dancing around on a zimmerframe by now, but it’s been put together so well that it would fit in fine on any 2012 dancefloor. Top marks.

Loreen – Euphoria

Tim: The winner. Of Melodifestivalen, and of Eurovision itself. Deserved?

Tom: Yes.

Tim: Oh yes.

Tom: And I think anyone who knew the tracks in advance could have called it. It’s the only one in there which sounds like it deserves to be at the top of every chart in Europe.

Tim: EXACTLY.

Now I’ll be frank: there were others I preferred. Jedward did well for Ireland, I enjoyed Malta with their on-stage DJ and fancy footwork, and Gréta Salóme & Jónsi’s Iceland performance was a highlight for me. But this— this victory is manna from above for us Eurovision fans. Because here we have a winner that’s acceptable worldwide, by the general populace.

Tom: The UK had Love Shine A Light back in the nineties, and – of course – Lena’s Satellite did the same for most of Europe if not the UK. This is the trouble with the British entries: we keep sending somewhat-silly entries, and we keep getting knocked down.

Tim: I don’t know about silly entries – Blue last year took it seriously and did well, and everyone involved genuinely thought The Hump had a good chance this year. But you’re right that people think of it as silly, but maybe that’ll change a bit. Because people can comment on how Eurovision’s ridiculous, or a terrible collection of music, or that the best song never wins, but then we’ll say, “But what about Loreen? That went top 10 all across Europe, got a great deal of radio airplay and was big in clubs all summer long, and that’s a Eurovision graduate.”

Now, I’m perhaps exaggerating a bit, and possibly getting my hopes up too much. But this was at number 1 on iTunes in the UK within eighteen hours of being performed. This is a big tune, and possibly, and hopefully, this generation’s Waterloo.

Tom: I’m not going to go that far: Waterloo’s what I’d call a “wedding disco song”, and perhaps only one or two tracks every year graduate into that kind of utterly mainstream, known-by-everyone success. (Recently: I Gotta Feeling and Party Rock Anthem.) But is it going to be the summer’s European hit? Almost certainly. And it deserves to be.

Saturday Reject: Danny Saucedo – Amazing

It deserves to do very well. Oh, wait. It didn’t. Never mind.

Tim: So, tonight’s the night, but we’ve just got time for one more reject. Let’s make it a bloody brilliant one, and one that it seems a bit unfair to put in a post with ‘Reject’ in the title – it did, in fact, get more phone votes than most previous Melodifestivalen winners did. Still, those are the rules, so here we go.

This year’s Melodifestivalen, a tad below the usual standard, started out as a two-horse race, really, and then, following a brilliant performance of Loreen’s Euphoria in her semi-final and technical issues in Danny’s semi-final performance, became closer to a one-point-five-horse race, ending with her getting 32% of the phone votes, this song getting 22% and the next one getting 8%. And here it is.

Tom: That’s possibly the best Eurovision intro I’ve heard all year. Admittedly that’s because it sounds like they copy-and-pasted it from the end of a Coldplay track, but still, full marks.

Tim: So many things to mention. Take the outfits. ‘Bloody hell, what is that weird thing he’s wearing?’ I thought, until about forty seconds in, when I thought, ‘BLOODY HELL, WHAT IS THAT BRILLIANT THING HE’S WEARING?’ I’m going clothes shopping tomorrow, and I’m not coming back until I’ve found one of those. (White or black, I’m not bothered.)

Tom: Electroluminescent wire, or EL wire for short. It’s brilliant stuff – been around for years, but it wasn’t until last year’s America’s Got Talent that it hit the mainstream.

Tim: Yeah, but when’s it going to hit Topshop, that’s what I want to know.

But then there’s also the breakdown. Normally, as we know, I’m not a dubstep fan, and a breakdown like this would put me right off the song. (If I’m honest, when I listen to the studio version it does put me off a little bit.) With this performance, my God is it fantastic. It’s perfect: people who think Eurovision’s cack will be impressed by the musical variety, and people who love Eurovision will ignore the music and focus on the pretty colours.

Tom: Not to mention he’s singing live while also managing a complicated dance routine. That’s trickier than it looks – and it looks tricky.

Tim: It does, and the dancing’s exceptionally good – take a look at the bit just after 1:40, because if I hadn’t been watching this live I’d swear blind there was a cut there.

There’s the lyrics as well – you don’t get long to get your song’s meaning across in Eurovision, what with it being a three-minute song only being heard once, and lyrics often go unnoticed. I don’t really think that’s a problem here, though, because it’s fairly simple and it’s being yelled at the audience enough it’ll probably be a crowd-pleaser.

Tom: It certainly pleased me.

Tim: As for the rest of it, the woo-oa-oah bits in the chorus remind me of Save The World, which is just as great, and overall there’s such a fantastic vibe to everything – music, dancers, ‘I’m feeling great, I’m feeling awesome…I think you’re amazing’ – that this song surely can’t really fail to please. Can it?

Tom: I hope not. It deserves to do very well. Oh, wait. It didn’t. Never mind.

Tim: More votes than almost all the previous winners. I think it’s done well enough, even if it didn’t win. Speaking of doing well, I’ve written quite a lot about this song, and entirely resisted the temptation to describe this as amazing. I’m proud of myself.