Tim: It’s not been long sine we last covered them, but here’s their first track of 2012.
Tom: YES.
Tom: OH DEAR.
Tim: Indeed. It’s really not the best song they’ve done – in fact, I’d say it’s a considerable dip below the average, with a few things I’m not so keen on.
Tom: All the component parts of Scooter are there, but somehow they just don’t work together this time. It’s not happy enough. It’s not mad enough. It’s not high-pitched enough.
Tim: In a nut-shell, yes. There’s the auto-tune, say. I can sort of understand them auto-tuning the chorus (although I’d have preferred it if they’d record original vocals), but why stick auto-tune on the main man himself? It doesn’t seem right.
Tom: It sounds like a track “featuring Scooter”. The emphasis isn’t on them – it’s on that lead vocal.
Tim: Yes, that’s just it, actually. Also, it’s just struck me that the best Scooter tracks have started out higher-pitched – that is, started with singing, or with some of the upbeat tuney bits. This, though, starts out heavy with HP giving it all he’s got, and it doesn’t really give you much time to duck out or get a bit warmed up. Is that a valid criticism? It seems a bit silly, but I think I’d prefer this if we went straight to the chorus at the start.
Tom: I know it’s a proper name and all that, but it means different quaintly amusing things in the US and the UK. If you’re going to try and make your stage name one word, surely you’d pick a different one?
Tim: You know, I was going to try to find out what her real name was, but then I figured that typing ‘fanny play’ into Google probably wouldn’t give me the results I was looking for.
Tom: In the interests of science, I checked. It pointed me at a 1932 play called “Fanny” by Marcel Pagnol. Disappointingly accurate results, there.
Tim: Oh. Oh well. Anyway, Play did the delightful Destiny that we featured a while back. Disappointingly, this is entirely different.
Tim: Is this a bit dull? From the start, yes, and indeed for at least the first two thirds.
Tom: It’s got an excellent intro. Sadly, that intro lasts about two minutes.
Tim: Sure, it builds up a little bit forty seconds from the end, but not nearly enough to qualify as exciting. If I’m being honest I wouldn’t have bothered bringing this up at all if I wasn’t immature enough to find her name a bit funny. Especially at the seventeen second mark.
Feeling mateless? Just been dumped? Then this is the video for you.
Tim: Feeling mateless? Just been dumped? Then this is the video for you.
Tom: Also if you want an introduction that reminds you of both Dido and Whigfield.
Tim: So we have here a lady who’s just been broken up with, but tells us she’s alright because she’s got her friends. Well, either that break-up hit her very hard indeed emotionally or I’m entirely sympathetic to the bloke who chucked her. Because, and I’m sorry to break this to you if you’re reading this, Aura, that’s not a friend – it’s a weird shoe-robot that’s the weirdest type of companion I’ve seen since Lauri’s weird puppet thing, Amanda, about a year ago.
Tom: She’d get on well with Olly Murs, then. Although her companion is rather well animated, I must say.
Tim: Well-animated, yes. But MADE OF SHOES.
Basically, Aura, you shouldn’t be playing backgammon with it, you shouldn’t be baking a cake with it, you should be making actual friends and moving on – maybe even ask that nice policeman out on a date, rather than lying to him about your weird-is-putting-it-lightly house guest. Because what sort of a message are you sending out? That everyone will be happy after a breakup if they can only build a robot out of their obscene collection of footwear? Come on now.
Tom: Well, quite. Er, the music, though?
Tim: Oh yes, we probably should talk about it. Well, there’s a dec—OH BLOODY HELL SHE WEARS LAMPSHADES ON HER HEAD, so can’t we just move on?
Tom: I thought it was quite a good track, actually.
Tom: Is it anywhere near as good as “We No Speak Americano”?
Tim: Prediction: no.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vP9UJdZlYww
Tom: No.
Tim: Good good – I love being right.
Tom: It starts badly. Then you get the rising synth in the background, and you think it might turn brilliant, and… it doesn’t. Then you’ve got the retro gramophone-type music coming out the back, another euphoric build… an extra bit on the end…
…and still nothing.
Tim: It’s sort of, let’s do roughly what we did when we had that successful track and hope it turns out good. And then let’s release it without bothering to check if it is good. Lets ignore the fact the four-bar-repeating-thing here is nowhere near as a catchy or vibrant as the four-bar-repeating-thing was last time – let’s just assume that people will buy this on the back of our other success.
Tom: This isn’t good dance. It isn’t good electroswing. It’s existing somewhere in the middle, trying to be both but managing neither.
Tim: This came an incredibly close second in the Austrian race, and we’ll discuss this for a few reasons, not least of which is that it gives me the chance to point out that the winning entry is by the group Trackshittaz.
Tom: Well, that’s going to be an interesting name for Graham Norton to handle. Anyway, on with the show!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RDuHTfFVCig
Tim: I’m not too sure of what Conchita’s all about – the internet seems evenly split between drag act, entire fictional personality or genuine transsexual.
German Wikipedia and the official website indicate the second one, but as far as the song goes, this is very definitely passing along a Born This Way style message that accompanies the third.
Tom: The papers won’t have to deal with another Dana International, then. If it wasn’t for the beard, they wouldn’t care or notice – but this is prob… whoa. Okay, half way through writing this, the first chorus kicked in, and my word that’s quite a voice.
Tim: Isn’t it just? Whatever the act’s about, it’s a bloody powerful song, the chorus especially.
Tom: I feel the verses let it down a bit too far – there’s more than just contrast with the choruses, there’s actually a bit of buzzkill there.
Tim: I’m hard-pressed not to agree with you there, but even so, once those lights are going off over the place, it’s hard to shake the feeling that THIS IS DRAMA. Just a slight shame the cameraman tripped up at the end, really.
Tom: I wonder if that was enough of a blip to affect the voting, if it really was That Close?
Tom: No, you read that right. Featuring Brian May. What’s even more surprising? This is actually a very good track.
Tim: Well bugger me.
Tom: Blatant use of drugs in the video as well, which would mark it as a very British track even if it wasn’t for the I’m A Celebrity reference in there. There’s no way that’d fly in a mainstream US video.
I have an enormous amount of respect for Brian May. I don’t need to run through his achievements in either music or astrophysics. My question isn’t “why is he slumming it with Dappy” because he’s blatantly not slumming it: this is an absolutely amazing bit of pop music. And no, I didn’t think I’d be saying that.
Tim: It is. Weirdly (actually, probably not weirdly) I’d never thought of Dappy as someone who actually sang – just a hip-hiop rapper who called himself a singer. But here he is, doing just that, and it sounds good.
Tom: Here’s my question: why is Brian May so criminally underused on this track? It’s a full three minutes before you even start to hear that trademark guitar sound. Sure, he might be noodling about in the earlier bits, but unless you’ve got that precise combination of effects that say “THIS IS A ROCK GOD, SHUT UP AND PAY ATTENTION” – the ones you heard when he smashed the grand finale at Reading Festival last year – who’s going to know it?
Tim: Best guess? If he was on there more he’d outshine Dappy just by being him and Dappy being Dappy (bloody hell that’s a a stupid name – how have I not noticed it before?), and Brian May fans would be all over it saying who’s this stupid bloke singing?
Tim: Yesterday, you’ll recall, we heard a piano dance track and discussed whether or not it needed vocals. Now, I’m going to ignore what you said about being bored of stuff, and will instead do, well not quite the same thing, because this one already has vocals.
Tom: About time.
Tim: This sounds great, and I think it backs up what I said.
Tom: Whereas I think it’s pretty much ripped my argument apart. ‘Cos I’m actually less enthused about this than yesterday’s repetitive piano track.
Tim: Really? The backing’s there to enjoy, and the vocals are on top in case it gets boring, which it certainly never does.
Tom: Is that backing really a melody on its own, though? It just sounds like regular background synth playing to me – no special little riffs being repeated there, just chords.
Tim: Yes, but they’re decent chords – they’ve got energy, vibrancy, something which yesterday’s didn’t have.
Tom: But that doesn’t make… “piano-dance” or whatever you call this genre. The piano’s not taking the lead melody, or even echoing it – it’s just a bit of the backing.
Tim: Well, it’s there enough to be notable. Though, in a weird twist, towards the end of the song I think it almost gets a bit too much. Like I said yesterday, you either need a complex melody or something like a vocal, but here we’ve got both. I’d certainly like to hear an instrumental version, just to compare the two.
Tom: I’d like to hear something… more. And I wish I could quantify that.
Tim: We have here a dance track. And I don’t really think it needs much of an introduction.
Tom: It does have a cracking introduction of its own.
Tim: It does – the opening notes are unusual, until you realise they aren’t actually anything to do with the song, but are instead just a title sequence, but after that we still have a good opening first verse for a poppy dance track. It ends, though, with what would ideally be a drop into a big and heavy chorus, but is actually comparatively something of a disappointment. It’s not dull, it’s just a bit let-downy.
Tom: After that brilliant first bit, I was really expecting a heavy chorus, but it wasn’t to be. The second chorus – after I’d got over that surprise – I like a lot more.
Tim: Yes, and on the other hand, that middle eight is pretty great – it’s got that type of synth in it that reminds me of eurotrance from ten years ago and it’s brilliant.
Tom: Not only that, but the video has the blatantly “not quite erotic enough to get banned” dancing from that era. And we’ve previously established that I’m a sucker for Americana videos, particularly ones set in deserts. In short: yes, I like it.
Tim: Me too, ish – towards the end it finally gets going properly, and it’s, well, pretty good. It finishes on a high, sure, but it’s a high that’s at the level the rest of the song should be at, and the closing bit should be even better. This wouldn’t get me to put down my drink and head onto the dancefloor; a heavy enough remix, though, definitely would.
“Yep, I totally brought philosophy into a bubblegum pop music review. DEAL WITH IT.”
Tim: Dance Dance Revolution fans, fire up your consoles please.
Tom: Wait, I don’t see ‘Saturday Flashback’ up there. They’re still going? Wow.
Tim: Slight personnel change, but yep. Still going.
Tom: Like many Eurodance groups, they’re a Trigger’s Broom problem: if you’ve replaced all the component parts, is it still the same item?
Yep, I totally brought philosophy into a bubblegum pop music review. DEAL WITH IT.
Tim: I’ll deal with that, but Trigger’s Broom? Mate, we’re a pop music blog. I think you’ll find it’s called the Sugababes Conundrum.
Tim: Here, we have an example of slightly wishful thinking. Dream about somebody, try to find him on the internet (despite a total lack of evidence that he actually exists), unsurprisingly fail, and then he phones you up on a good strong 4G connection. Sounds reasonable, right?
Tom: Smile.DK songs had two good points when they featured in DDR games: first of all they were over-the-top cheesy, and secondly they were cut down to only 90 seconds long. This one seems to lack both of those. The plot of the song isn’t really important.
Tim: Well, the plot isn’t hugely important, no, but it does matter that you’re so happy it’s happened that you throw in one of the most ridiculous key-changes this side of Evergreen. Perfect day all round, really.
Tom: The strange thing is this: I don’t like the song. So why on earth did I start tapping my foot after that key change? Suddenly that bit of uplift made it all better. What’s wrong with me?
Oh my word, it’s like the Eurovision of the 1990s has come back to haunt us.
Tom: The last chance before Jedward. What’ve we got?
Tim: The cheap route for the video here, going for the ‘let’s take some cameras into the recording studio and film it a few times’ method. And fill it out with some waffle at the end about how we want you to vote for us. Believe it or not.
Tom: Oh my word, it’s like the Eurovision of the 1990s has come back to haunt us.
Tim: If only.
The good thing about this video, and in particular the ‘cut the screen up to show what’s happening’ effect, is that is helps to point out that while this starts out fairly sensible, it gradually gets more and more excited throughout the song, until we get to about 2:30, when we’ve got nine things going on at once and it can only really be described as ‘batshit crazy’.
Tom: This is the first of the Irish songs where I’ve found my foot automatically tapping along. Which means it’s good – it’s also incredibly cheesy, though, and while it’d do well ten years ago (Love Shine A Light, anyone?) the rest of Europe is looking for modern pop music, not something that could have been written as a dodgy anthem for the Barcelona Olympics.
Tim: Oh, but I like the cheese.
Tom: I do, in general, but this is too much: this is a whole industrial-size buffet-style fondue set. It reminds me of the Brittas Empire for some reason. That’s not a good thing.
Tim: I think this is fantastic, I really do, because, well, there’s just so much happening. Even though the video makes it look like David has to consult his lyrics sheet on a couple of occasions, everything and everyone just seems so energised – they have PURPLE VIOLINS, for crying out loud. The two of them seem to be competing with regard to who can sing most enthusiastically, and part of me wouldn’t be surprised if it turned out they decided to throw that key change in on the day just for the hell of it.
This is amazing, brilliant, almost out of this world pop music, and I love it.
Tom: And it’ll do terribly if Ireland picks it. Which is a great shame.
In fact, I’m going to go off on one now, about everyone (especially the Great British Public every time our song is chosen) who say ‘oh, it’s not a Eurovision song.’ I wrote a thing on my long-defunct Canada blog a couple of years back after the 2010 contest. Full thing’s here, but two important sentences are:
‘[When it started in 1956] the idea was that each country would join in, play what they thought was good music, and hope that other countries would agree with them.
Basically, my point is that there’s no such thing as a Eurovision song and we should choose music we like, and I’d hoped that you would agree.
Tom: It depends whether you want to follow that original idea – play good music and hope people agree – or whether you want to win. I’m talking about these with the latter in mind.
Tim: No – you’ve completely missed my point, which is that it’s pointless choosing them based on ‘what’s going to win’, because there’s no way of predicting it. Like I said earlier, last year’s winner wasn’t far off this in cheese terms, and who the hell would have predicted a victory for Lordi?
But even if you’re right, and if it would do terribly, I don’t care about that – I want it performed on a massive stage, with insane production values (sadly the Late Late Show set isn’t really built for that), if only to see what they come up with.