Andrew Mann – Here I Am

This is proper lighters-in-the-air stuff and it’ll get votes.

Tim: This guy’s taking this thing seriously – it was up on iTunes within hours of being unveiled on the radio, and there’s an official video and everything.

Tom: And yet, he still doesn’t stand a chance against Jedward.

Tim: The obvious thing about this is the very military snare drum in the background, which wouldn’t be a bad thing, if there was something else to draw attention from it. There’s the piano, sure, and the guitars –

Tom: — wait, isn’t that —

Tim: Yes, before you interrupt me, I have just described a full backing orchestration, but if you’ll let me continue – it’s the drums that stand out. The piano’s only audible in the quiet bits, when the drums are there as well, and the heavy guitars, rather than taking this back towards friendly happy music, only make it seem more serious, more soldier-like, and overall less fun.

Tom: See, I’d use some different words there: “anthemic” and “emotional”. That second line of the chorus, with the rising chords, is just beautiful. I can see this doing very well – maybe not top of the table, but this is proper lighters-in-the-air stuff and it’ll get votes.

Tim: Oh, probably. It’s listenable, sure, and it’s a decent song – just, did you have to choose that backing?

Tom: I’m glad he did. Compress that much emotion into that space of time, and I think you’ve got a decent chance.

Donna McCaul – Mercy

“This song surprised me. You’ll see why.”

Tom: All right, we’ve got three days left before we have the Friday Jedward Punchline. What’ve you got from Ireland today?

Tim: You keep saying that, and now I’m thinking I’d like to punch them on Friday. But anyway, this song surprised me. You’ll see why.

Tim: Yes. The key change. Because this is a song I can, without too much difficulty, imagine coming out of the mouth of Rihanna, Nicki Minaj, Ke$ha, that lot. And those people don’t do key changes – they’re not right for a song, they’re outdated, they’re only there to spice up an otherwise dull ending. But here, despite coming at exactly the right moment in a Eurovision song, it’s so unexpected that it’s absolutely brilliant.

Tom: Something I can’t believe I’m saying: it’s a modern Eurovision song coming from west of the North Sea. Which means it won’t stand a chance in the Irish public vote, but it’s not bad at all.

Tim: As for the rest of it? The rap breakdown in the middle is odd – not musically (see previous Nicki Minaj comparison), but certainly Eurovisionally (or at least, stereotypically Eurovisionally – maybe this whole week will be about challenging preconceived ideas).

Tom: Rap breakdowns don’t generally do well in Eurovision, but I reckon this stands a good chance because of Ke$ha and her ilk paving the way first.

Tim: I think you’re right there. It certainly fits well in the song, and while this is one of my least favourites of the bunch it’s still a decent tune, very poppy and, as you say, very likely to do at least fairly well if it makes it to Baku.

Tom: Right – this could play well in Europe, and – for Ireland – that’s what the public should be voting on.

Maria McCool – Mistaken

Starts out like it’s just stepped off a boat from Rivendell.

Tim: This year, like last year, Ireland has five songs in its shortlist for Eurovision. This year, unlike last year, they’re all rather good, and several are excellent. They’re being decided this Friday, so let’s take them one at a time.

Tom: Hold on. There’s one particular song in there that I’m worried about. Are you just leading up to a Jedward Friday Punchline?

Tim: They’re scheduled fifth, yes, but until then, let’s start with number one:

Tim: Starts out like it’s just stepped off a boat from Rivendell, but quickly cheers up a bit. Maintains that Celtic folky feel throughout – sounds properly old-school Irish, a bit like what you’d hear if you were to imagine a leprechaun school disco.

Tom: No, I think you’ll find that this is exactly that. It seems to be the Irish equivalent of a Bollywood disco. (Side note: how compressed is that music? The melody drops out every time there’s a bass kick!)

Tim: Perhaps the compression algorithm rewards those who put effort into the music; one of the cheapest dance tracks of the past decade doesn’t really stand a chance. (Still must confess to liking it, though.)

Anyway, I do realise that I may have just insulted an entire nation and its long and distinguished history, with that first sentence, but it’s meant in a good way, I promise.

Tom: Mm. Let’s move on quickly.

Tim: Well you see, I don’t know much about what Ireland’s currently producing musically, but as far as I’m concerned, Eurovision should be about a country and its music coming together, and if this is it, then bring it on.

Tom: So for each of these songs, I’m judging them on a different criterion than usual: are they likely to win Eurovision? And my verdict for this is: no. No it’s not. Middle to bottom of the table, not likely to get through the semi-final, I reckon. And is it really Irish music coming together?

Tim: That’s the thing – and if all this does is help perpetuate, via people like me, an old and out-dated stereotype that Ireland is full of little green men with bells on their hats and shoes, always going on about pots o’ gold, it’s probably best left at home, far away from Azerbaijan.

Tom: Especially if they want to score points.

Darin – Nobody Knows

It’s good. It’s very good.

Tim: Every Darin track we (or certainly I) review will inevitably be compared to Lovekiller – it was big, it was exciting, it was fantastic, and it was actually pretty much the track that inspired the creation of this blog. So how does the lead single off his new album compare?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6l9efZUVNKA

Tim: Hmm. It’s good. It’s very good. It’s more ravey than previously material, and it has a very similar ‘crank it up to seventeen right from the start’ vibe to it.

Tom: It cranks it up just late enough for it to count as some kind of ‘drop’ – but what a brilliant drop it is. I wish there was a bit more low-frequency bass oomph in there, but perhaps that’s just YouTube compression.

Tim: That first chorus is a closing section all in itself. But – and this is a fairly big but – this gets bored. It does a standard ‘drop down to very little’ in the middle eight, and comes back as it was.

Tom: See, I think you’re being too harsh on it. It’s not on maximum all the way through – you’ve missed at least the first verse, which is even quieter than the middle eight. It is, in short, bloody marvellous.

Tim: You’re right – I’m being unreasonably negative.

Tom: Yes you are.

Tim: If I knew nothing about Darin, or it was a different artist, I’d think: this is brilliant. The second half is as normal, with a quiet middle eight and big close, but the first half is amazingly better that it’s expected to be. And that is what this review should be, because this is a great song. It’s just – I can’t help but compare the two, and that annoys me.

Tom: This track makes me want to dance like an idiot. That’s about the highest praise I can give it.

Matt Cardle – Amazing

Ah, Credibility Cardle. What’s he up to?

Tim: Ah, Credibility Cardle. What’s he up to?

Tom: He’s still going, and probably still a bit annoyed that Olly Murs is doing so well.

Tom: But I’d like to revise my opinion of Matt Cardle: if you file him under what the radio stations refer to as “adult contemporary” rather than “pop”, then he’s absolutely brilliant. He’s not aiming for Radio 1; he’s aiming for Radio 2. You can tell by the nice, probably meaningful, slow video.

Tim: Hmm. If I were you I’d get rid of ‘nice’ and replace it with ‘boring’. Look at me, I’m playing a guitar. I’m not an X Factor winner – I’m a Credible Rock Musician. And just to show how deep and emotional my songs probably are, because people really aren’t going to be able to listen to my lyrics without slipping into a coma, let’s have some people crying for no good reason.

Tom: I think you’re confusing “different” with “bad” there.

Tim: Absolutely not – I’m a Serious Music Reviewer, and I do not confuse those things (much). What I am doing is allowing my personal dislike for Matt Cardle’s attitude to interfere with my discussion of this track. And that is something I am PERFECTLY ENTITLED TO DO.

Tom: It’s a textbook Radio 2 track. It’s great. It’s an anthemic, slowly building, guitar-and-everything track that makes me smile. It’s the kind of thing that Almighty Records will remix.

Tim: Speaking of which, who wants a Christina Perri cover?

Tom: Ooh, good post hijack. Bit of a weird intro, but it picks up fast. A quick warning to readers, though: the video attached to that track is just a scantily-clad arse, so do watch out if you’re at work.

Anyway. In other words, Cardle’s being a bit like Snow Patrol. Probably a bit too much like Snow Patrol, actually.

Still good, though.

Tim: Oh, it’s alright, I suppose. And exactly what an ‘I HATE X FACTOR but actually I owe everything I have to it but I HATE IT’ X Factor winner should aim to come out with.

Martin Solveig and Dragonette feat. Idoling!!! – Big in Japan

Less tennis, less sanity.

Tom: Last time we heard from Martin Solveig, he’d hit the big time with “Hello” and had a video of himself playing tennis against Bob Sinclar.

Tom: This time, there’s less tennis, less sanity, and a much less catchy track.

Tim: Same amount of bassline in fact. Or, more concisely, same bassline.

Tom: It’s still clearly Martin Solveig – it sounds like he’s just tweaking his synth settings a bit to create what is now his trademark sound. But the melody on top of it just isn’t the same.

Tim: No. What is it, actually? I can’t remember.

Tom: It doesn’t have that same kind of shout-along, dance-along quality that Hello did. It’s not bad – but if he’s going to put out something this close to his last big hit, then he’s got to be careful that the first thought you get isn’t “the last one was better”.

Tim: Actually, I reckon the first thought most people would have is ‘what’s this weird mash-up of Hello?’

It could be argued, though, that this is actually a very different song – the first was, let’s be honest, just a chorus (can you remember anything else of it?), whereas this one has nothing particularly memorable at all, much as a track without any chorus would likely be.

It’s not bad – danceable and all that – but with that intro, people (i.e. excited clubbers who love the big hits) will be disappointed it’s not what they were expecting.

Adam Lambert – Better Than I Know Myself

The fangirls will be happy.

Tim: Stand aside for the weird-concept video, please, which today contains an excessive amount of oxygen and lapels. And, as it happens, Adam Lamberts.

Tom: Plural? The fangirls will be happy.

Tim: First off, children, can we please not use this video as a substitute for a physics lesson. Or at the very least, not that oxygen meter thingy, which is wrong on just so many levels I can’t possibly ignore it, desperate as I am to do so. But let’s move on.

Tom: Second up, that is a spectacular hairstyle. I mean, I have to respect anyone who takes their cues from Sonic the Hedgehog.

Tim: I don’t know if that’s meant to be an insult, but if it is, it’s a bit rich coming from the man who takes his cues from Professor Snape.

Tom: Now that’s harsh. “Lank and greasy and flopping onto the table?”

…wait, you’re just going to do a cock joke now, aren’t you?

Tim: Actually, I was thinking we really, desperately, need to move on to the song.

What we have here is him singing to (one would presume) an unspecified boy/girlfriend, something along the lines of ‘I know I’m acting weird, but please don’t dump me because even though I may give the impression I want to leave you I don’t’.

Tom: Musically, I’m not all that impressed: having listened to it twice now, I still can’t remember it at all. Is there anything catchy in there? I’m really not sure.

Tim: Not hugely catchy, no, but the video gives an extra bit, which warrants discussion.

Unleashed last Friday, it adds to the lyrics nicely, with an idea of ‘the main reason you think I want to leave you is that the evil half of my mind is currently trying to murder the good half of my brain, so be perfectly honest I’m a little bit too busy to bother with all this relationship faff’.

Tom: Ah, the classic. Boy meets girl, girl likes boy, boy turns out to have two disparate warring personalities.

Tim: Such a classic tale.

The big debate here, of course, is: is he being too self-centred? Some would argue he is, but personally, I can see where he’s coming from, especially when Evil Adam pulls out his own heart and squelches it a bit.

Tom: And Evil Adam has significantly better makeup.

Tim: And significantly bigger lapels. Yes, it’s the second time I’ve mentioned them, but THEY’RE BLOODY MASSIVE.

An alternative interpretation, though, is that this song is a message from one Adam to the other, and what we have here is a remarkably open and public major psychological breakdown. That could be quite fun to watch, actually.

Tom: I think it’d be more fun than this song.

Amanda Mair – Sense

Serious music.

Tim: I think this’ll remind you slightly of a TV show theme tune. Because it did me.

Tim: And that’s a shame, because this is a vaguely alright song, and it’s just those five notes that remind me that NBC have shelved one of my favourite shows for the time being and haven’t said when they’ll bring it back.

Tom: Ah, Community. One of the best shows on television. Well, not on television any more, but still. Bit of a coincidence, by the way – our regular reader Roger just sent this same track to me after reading quite a bit about Amanda Mair. “With this single,” he says, “I understand the hype!”

Tim: Well, in that case we should probably discuss this music properly. Though actually let’s not, because to be honest, I think it’s a bit dull. Decent enough to listen to in the background, sure, and a good voice, but’s there’s nothing to really get excited about, for me anyway. It’s like it’s being serious music, as though pop music isn’t allowed to be fun any more.

Tom: Now, this is where I disagree really strongly with you. This is fun. It’s not a three-minute Eurovision spectacular, sure, and it’s got a bit more meaning behind it than the formulaic stuff – but that doesn’t mean it isn’t fun. It’s jaunty. It’s entertaining. I’m not going to be singing along to it any time soon, but it’s rather nice.

Tim: You think? Well, actually, speaking of entertaining, the video is worth mentioning, if only because I don’t like it because it’s weird and, well, doesn’t make sense (that may well be the point given that that’s the main theme of the song, but if it is then they should make it obvious and make it properly not make sense). What’s with all the signs? No idea, but if anybody does I’ll be more than happy to hear it.

Hmm. Am I coming across as a bit negative here?

Tom: Well, yes, really. Quite unjustifiably.

Tim: Rubbish. This song seems to have put me in a bad mood, and I have no idea why.

Tom: I wonder if it has that effect on anyone else?

Anna Abreu – Be With You

Almost New Wave-y synths.

Tim: Now if I remember rightly you recently didn’t like it when the track title got repeated a lot. Well, good luck with this, the fourth and final release from last year’s album Rush.

Tom: Ooh, it starts well, doesn’t it? Almost New Wave-y synths on there, which is a good thing with modern pop production.

Tim: I like this, sort of. Really, actually, and right from the first few notes, because everything that’s there is great. It’s just what’s not there that’s the problem – there’s a continuing sense of build, right up to the first half of each chorus, and then it suddenly drops down, to pretty much nothing. Now that’s not really a problem – we hear anti-climaxes all the time, and I can generally cope.

Tom: That said, the first half of each chorus is lovely – almost a climax in themselves.

Tim: True, I suppose, but here that’s just not good enough. You see, here we have those three underlying notes, repeating. To me, they sound like the ticking of a bomb hidden somewhere in a car. You can’t see the timer, so you don’t know when it’ll happen, but you know it’ll explode. Even when (perhaps especially when) there’s just the very calm ‘just want to be with you’ over them, those notes could go off at any time. And you know they will go off. The song will go from ‘good’ to ‘immense’, because of that inevitable explosion. There’s just no way it can’t. Except, it doesn’t. And I think that’s a bit rubbish.

Tom: I think we need a new category on this blog: “Musical Blueballs”.

Tim: Hmm. Can’t quite see that getting picked up by mainstream music journalists, but it’ll do for us.

Tone Damli – Look Back

A very good, country-influenced pop song.

Tim: I don’t really have any introduction for this.

Tom: Fortunately, neither does she.

Tim: This is standard, really. And there’s not a whole lot to say about it. But I like it, so we’re featuring it.

Tom: It’s a very good, country-influenced pop song. (There’s a cry break or two in there.) We’ve said on several occasions that there’s nothing wrong with being formulaic, provided both the formula and the execution are decent – and in this case, they really are.

Tim: True. Some artistic people might spout some crap about how it’s all rubbish if you don’t express your true creativity, to which I say: bollocks. We’ve got a decent enough tune, a good voice (came second in Norwegian Idol 2005), some nice instruments and a triumphant energetic closing bit. All good, really.